Hamsters vs Guinea Pigs: Which Pet Is Right for You?

Rachel M.
by Rachel M.

Hamsters and guinea pigs are two of the most popular small pets, especially for young children.


While they both may be small and cute, they have notably different personalities, needs, and care requirements.


Understanding their differences will help you decide which furry companion suits you best.

Guinea pig - image via Canva

1. Personality and temperament

Hamsters

  • Typically solitary creatures. Most breeds, especially Syrian hamsters, prefer to live alone and can become territorial if housed with others.
  • They’re most active at night, so expect them to run on their wheel at 2 a.m.
  • They can be curious and friendly if handled regularly, but sudden movements may startle them.


Guinea Pigs

  • Social animals that thrive in pairs or small groups. In fact, in some countries it’s illegal to keep a guinea pig alone.
  • Diurnal tendencies (awake during the day) make them more interactive with humans at convenient times.


  • They’re generally gentle, vocal, and affectionate, making them great for families.


2. Size and Space Needs

Hamsters

  • Smaller and require less cage space. However, they need lots of enrichment like tunnels, wheels, and chew toys.
  • A large hamster cage should have at least 775 square inches of floor space. Many store-bought cages are actually too small.


Guinea Pigs

  • Larger and need significantly more room.
  • Guinea pigs need significantly more space, with additional room for each additional animal.
  • They also need floor time outside the cage for exercise.
Hamster on wheel - image via Canva

3. Diet and Care

Hamsters

  • Eat commercial hamster pellets, supplemented with seeds, grains, fruits, and vegetables.
  • Require daily spot cleaning of their cage and a full clean weekly.


Guinea Pigs

  • Eat a diet of hay (80% of intake), fresh vegetables, and guinea pig pellets fortified with vitamin C (they cannot produce their own).
  • Need constant access to fresh hay for digestion and dental health.
  • Cleaning needs are more intensive due to their size and waste output.

4. Lifespan and Commitment

Hamsters

  • Live around 2–3 years.
  • Short lifespan makes them a lower long-term commitment.


Guinea Pigs

  • Live 5–8 years on average, sometimes longer with excellent care.
  • Require a longer commitment in time, cost, and attention.

5. Noise and Interaction Level

Hamsters

  • Generally quiet, though they may squeak or make soft clicking sounds when excited or annoyed.
  • Noisy at night due to running wheels, chewing toys, or rearranging bedding.
  • Interaction is short and usually at their pace; handling during the day can stress them.


Guinea Pigs

  • Very vocal, with a range of sounds: “wheeking” (high-pitched calls) when hungry, gentle purring when content, and chattering teeth when annoyed.
  • Active during the day, making them more responsive to human interaction.
  • Enjoy gentle petting and can form strong bonds with owners.
Hamster - image via Canva

Bottom Line

  • Choose a hamster if you want a small, low-maintenance pet, have limited space, or are looking for a short-term commitment.


  • Choose a guinea pig if you want an affectionate, social animal, have room for a larger enclosure, and are ready for a longer-term companion.


Both animals bring lots of joy, but their different needs mean one will likely fit your lifestyle better than the other.


Do your research thoroughly and let us know your personal verdict in the comments down below.  



Join the PetGuide community. Get the latest pet news and product recommendations by subscribing to our newsletter here.

Rachel M.
Rachel M.

More by Rachel M.

Next