Here’s Why Your Dog Has a Favorite Toy

Rachel M.
by Rachel M.

If you’ve ever noticed your dog obsessively choosing one toy while ignoring the rest, you’re not imagining things.


Dogs can be surprisingly selective about their playthings, and a favorite toy often reveals a lot about their instincts, habits, and emotional needs.


Disclosure: PetGuide may receive a small affiliate commission from purchases made via links in this article at no cost to you.

Dog with cuddly toy - image via Canva

1. Toys as Comfort Items

Just like humans have favorite blankets or keepsakes, dogs often latch onto a toy that gives them comfort.


The texture, shape, and even scent of a toy can make it especially soothing. A plush toy might serve as a security blanket, perfect for cuddling or carrying around.


A ball, on the other hand, might satisfy a dog’s urge to chase and fetch. Over time, repeated positive experiences with a particular toy turn it into a familiar, comforting object that your dog seeks out again and again.

Original Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Puppy Toy - image via Amazon

2. Instincts at Play

A dog’s choice in toys often reflects their natural instincts and breed-specific traits.


For example:

  • Chewers like Labradors or Pit Bulls may gravitate toward durable rubber or nylon toys that satisfy their need to gnaw.


  • High-prey-drive breeds, such as many Terriers, often prefer squeaky toys that mimic the sounds and movements of prey.


When a toy aligns with these innate tendencies, it’s more likely to become a long-term favorite. Essentially, the toy is fulfilling a natural urge while keeping your dog entertained.

KONG Wild Knots Bear - image via Amazon

3. Emotional and Social Connections

Favorites aren’t just about instincts, they’re also about memories and bonds. Toys often become symbolic of your shared experiences: tug-of-war sessions, fetch in the yard, or quiet moments of companionship.


Because a beloved toy is tied to positive interactions, it can help your dog feel secure, even when they’re playing alone. This emotional connection also makes toys powerful tools for enrichment, reducing anxiety and preventing boredom.

rocket & rex Dog Chew Toy Set - image via Amazon

Keeping Play Healthy and Engaging

Even if your dog has a favorite, it’s important to keep playtime varied. Rotating toys introduces novelty, stimulates curiosity, and prevents obsessive behavior. Observe which toys truly spark your dog’s interest, and always choose items that are safe for their size and chewing habits.


Understanding why a dog favors certain toys offers insight into their personality and instincts. Beyond fun, play is a vital way for dogs to explore, express themselves, and strengthen their bonds with the people they love.


Join the PetGuide community. Get the latest pet news and product recommendations by subscribing to our newsletter  here.

Rachel M.
Rachel M.

More by Rachel M.

Next