Should I Be Using a Dog Harness Instead of a Collar?

Angela Vuckovic
by Angela Vuckovic
a katz/Shutterstock

When it comes to walking your dog, choosing between a harness and a collar might seem like a small detail - but it can actually have a big impact on your dog’s comfort, safety, and even behavior. If you’ve ever found yourself wondering, “Should I be using a harness instead of a collar?” you’re not alone. Let’s break down the pros and cons of each option, and help you figure out what might be best for your four-legged friend.


Collars: Simple, Traditional, and Convenient

For many dog owners, collars are the go-to choice. They’re easy to slip on, come in endless styles, and often double as ID holders.


The upsides:


  • Quick to put on and take off
  • Ideal for carrying ID tags and rabies/license info
  • Great for dogs that don’t pull on walks
  • Less bulky than a harness


But… not every dog does well with a collar alone. If your dog tends to pull, lunges on leash, or has certain medical issues (like tracheal collapse or neck injuries), a collar can cause strain on the neck, potentially leading to discomfort or injury.


Harnesses: A Comfortable Alternative

Harnesses distribute pressure across the chest and shoulders rather than the neck, which can be a huge advantage for certain dogs.


Benefits of using a harness:


  • Reduces pressure on the neck, especially for small breeds, brachycephalic dogs (like pugs or bulldogs), or dogs with respiratory issues
  • Offers better control for dogs that pull or are still in training
  • Can prevent escape in dogs that back out of collars
  • Many designs discourage pulling without pain


Downsides? Harnesses can take a little longer to put on, and not all dogs love the feeling of wearing one at first. But with some positive reinforcement, most pups adjust quickly.


So… Which One Should You Use?


The answer depends on your dog’s size, behavior, and health needs.

Stick with a collar if:


  • Your dog walks calmly on leash
  • You mostly use a harness for walks but want your dog to wear ID tags at home
  • You’re popping out for a quick potty break and need something quick


Switch to a harness if:


  • Your dog pulls on walks or needs better control
  • You have a toy breed or brachycephalic dog
  • Your pup is recovering from an injury or has a sensitive neck
  • You want a safer option for car rides (some harnesses double as seatbelt systems)


Can I Use Both?


Absolutely. Many dog owners use both a harness and a collar - a collar for everyday wear and ID, and a harness for walks and training. It’s all about what keeps your dog safe, happy, and comfortable.


Final Thoughts


A harness isn’t always better, but for many dogs, it’s definitely safer and more comfortable. If your walks feel more like a tug-of-war, or your pup coughs or hacks on the leash, it might be time to make the switch. And remember - whether you choose a harness, collar, or both, the best choice is the one that suits your dog’s needs and helps you enjoy stress-free adventures together.

Angela Vuckovic
Angela Vuckovic

A proud mama to seven dogs and ten cats, Angela spends her days writing for her fellow pet parents and pampering her furballs, all of whom are rescues. When she's not gushing over her adorable cats or playing with her dogs, she can be found curled up with a good fantasy book.

More by Angela Vuckovic

Next