Mexico and Brazil Duke it Out Over The Carmelo Street Dog

Mary Simpson
by Mary Simpson

A battle between two nations that has nothing to do with soccer balls and sports heroes? Read on?

(photo credit: Mary Swift / shutterstock.com)

Yes, the fight between Brazil and Mexico isn’t about pitches, penalties, and punts. It’s all about a tan little dog that both countries are claiming as their own.


In fact, just a couple of years back, Brazil’s iconic caramel colored dog was captured in a Netflix feel-good movie entitled Carmelo that followed the travails of a winsome street dog trying to catch a break. Filmed in Sao Paolo, it told the story of what Brazilians consider to be their national icon – the caramel-toned stray. Now, we’re not talking about this 200-million-plus population having a passive position about this pooch. We’re talking about a range of t-shirts, viral songs, floats in the local parades, and even a brush with placement on the country’s currency. That kind of popular. Yes, these tawny-toned street dogs are that important to the locals who share both space and food with them each day.


Enter Mexico. Now, if you’ve ever been to any of the resort towns in this Latin American country, you’ll note that they, too, have a burgeoning population of tan pooches milling around town and looking for a handout from the tourists. Are these tawny canine similarities simply a coincidence?


Not really. Dogs, over eons of time, adapt to their settings. And in hot weather climates, you’ll find those dogs to be lighter colored (to deflect heat), possessing a shorter, thinner coat to help them stay cool, possessing upright ears for breezy comfort and longer beaks for easier expulsion of hot air. You get the picture.


However, this is where it gets a little testy. A state in Mexico has now decided to dub these caramel canines its own iconic symbol. Yes, the Office of the Environmental Prosecutor in Mexico State has declared the “perro caramelo” dog to be a Mexican breed.


And this has Brazilians fighting mad.


Trying to referee between the two nations is animal welfare advocate Claudia Edwards with the Humane World for Animals non-profit. “Brazil was the first to recognize it, to put it on the map. The Brazilian people should be very proud of that.” The caramel stray doesn’t have to belong to one nation, she added. “It’s Latin American!”

I’m loving the diplomacy, but not convinced these hot-blooded countries will accept compromise. Isn’t it like awarding two MVP awards to opposing teams? And doesn’t Mexico already have the Chihuahua? Time will tell, but as they say in sports, it’s not over till the fat lady sings.


Mary Simpson
Mary Simpson

Sharing space with three seriously judgy Schnoodles and 2 felines who prefers to be left alone. #LivingMyBestLife

More by Mary Simpson

Next