The Pros and Cons of Automatic Litter Boxes
Automatic self-cleaning litter boxes are popular these days. But like all products, they come with benefits and drawbacks you should consider before making a purchase decision. Here’s a guide to some of the pros and cons of automatic cat litter boxes to help you make the right choice for your feline friend.
The Pros of Automatic Litter Boxes
These are some of the many reasons why people prefer automatic litter boxes:
Convenience: Remembering to scoop your cat’s litter box daily, or multiple times a day, can be tough when you lead a busy lifestyle, but self-cleaning litter boxes get the job done for you. Every time your kitty uses the box, it will scoop out the waste and deposit it in a receptacle you can empty out later. This saves you time and effort, and can help ensure your cat’s litter will always be clean and ready to use. Of course, you still have to make sure there is enough litter in the box at all times, and that you empty, clean, and refill the box as needed.
Less Odor: Automatic litter boxes for cats might help trap odor better than traditional litter boxes. As mentioned above, these boxes will clean themselves after your cat does their business. If the waste is removed promptly and kept in a sealed bin or waste drawer, you may not smell the litter box as much as you used to. The area around the box might not need to be deodorized, and the box itself may be less stinky and, therefore, more attractive to your cat, which helps reduce the risk of them eliminating outside the box.
Tracking Your Cat’s Litter Box Habits: Some automatic litter boxes are powered by AI to give you information about your kitty’s litter box habits and their health. For instance, they might send data to your smartphone to let you know about the number of times your cat uses the box and if they’re going more or less frequently, and might even help you track your pet’s weight.
Your Health: Some people have health concerns or disabilities that prevent them from safely and effectively cleaning their kitty’s litter box. And women who are pregnant may want to avoid cleaning the box. In these cases, automatic litter boxes do the work for you. Some automatic boxes will even dispose of the waste without you needing to empty a bin—a great example is the CatGenie Whoosh, which uses special litter, scoops waste, and washes it down the drain in your laundry room or bathroom.
The Cons of Automatic Litter Boxes
Despite the benefits they can provide, there are drawbacks to consider before getting a self-cleaning litter box. Those include:
Safety: Not all automatic litter boxes are safe. Sadly, there have been multiple news stories (like this one, as an example) and social media posts about cats getting injured or killed in their self-cleaning litter boxes. The products might be poorly designed, or might be poor-quality knockoffs of well-known brands. So, if you decide to get an automatic box, do careful and thorough research, and go with one that includes vital safety features and is manufactured by a reputable business.
Difficulty Monitoring Your Cat’s Health: Your cat’s bathroom habits provide insight into their health, but if you aren’t scooping their litter, you may miss important clues. For instance, if there’s blood in your cat’s urine from a urinary tract infection or blockage, or if they’re having diarrhea, discolored stool, or dry, hard stools indicative of constipation, you might not realize these problems are occurring because they’re being cleaned away and hidden. Sure, some boxes have apps that collect data, as discussed above, but that doesn’t replace actually seeing what’s coming out of your cat.
Cats Might Not Like It: Some cats don’t mind using self-cleaning litter boxes and might prefer them. But every cat is an individual, and some might not like these types of boxes for various reasons. For example, some boxes are covered, while others might be hard to get into or out of, especially for senior cats or those with problems like arthritis. Plus, if the litter box turns on automatically (in some cases, there’s a risk of this happening while your cat is still in the box, which can be dangerous) or makes loud or irritating sounds, those features might frighten or stress your kitty and potentially cause them to avoid the box.
Cost of Purchase, Maintenance, and Repairs: Automatic litter boxes vary in price based on manufacturer, model, and features, but they’re more expensive than the basic litter box you’d buy at a pet store. Some even cost hundreds of dollars. Also, like all electronic products, malfunctions can occur, and if the product is ever in need of repairs, those might be expensive, too. Plus, if there are any product-specific components or accessories you need to purchase on a recurring basis, those could add up, too.
The Litter You Need: Some self-cleaning litter boxes only work with certain types of litter or a specific type of litter, so your options are limited in those cases. And the litter required might be pricier than clay litter and other types of litter like eco-friendly options. Plus, if your kitty decides they don’t like the special litter, they may avoid using the box.
Only Use High-Quality, Safe Automatic Litter Boxes from Reputable Brands
If you want to give an automatic self-cleaning litter box a try, stick with reputable brands that have been around for a long time and have a positive reputation. Choose products known to be safe for cats.
One good option is the Litter-Robot 4 Supply & Accessory Bundle by Whisker. But there are a few other Litter-Robot models you can choose from, as this automatic litter box has been around for years and has become popular, so check those out as well. The Litter-Robot 4, in particular, can work in multi-cat households, has a carbon-filtered waste drawer to control odors, and works with the Whisker app to track your cat’s weight and litter box activity.
If you decide a regular litter box is the better way to go for you and your cats, check out the IRIS Open-Top Cat Litter Box with Shield and Scoop. It’s uncovered and open on the top for your cat’s comfort, but has high sides to help prevent messes on your floor. It also comes with a scoop, and the top half is removable for easy cleaning.
Weigh the Pros and Cons of Automatic Litter Boxes
There’s a lot to think about before deciding if an automatic litter box is worthwhile. Remember to gently introduce this new product to your cat, and know that it might take some time before they decide to use it.
One last tip: A common mistake is not having enough litter boxes. In single and multi-cat households, it’s best to have more than one box at all times, whether that’s multiple regular litter boxes, multiple automatic boxes, or a combination of the two types. This will help ensure there’s always a clean box when they need it.
Join the PetGuide community. Get the latest pet news and product recommendations by subscribing to our newsletter here.
Lisa Selvaggio is a freelance writer and editor, and our resident cats-pert, with certifications in pet nutrition and pet first aid. She enjoys producing content that helps people understand animals better so they can give their pets a safe and happy home.
More by Lisa Selvaggio