Why Does My Cat Drop Her Toys into Her Water Bowl?

Mary Simpson
by Mary Simpson

No surprise, instincts are in play.

(photo credit: Olga gaeva96 / shutterstock.com

Okay, again this morning, I’ve had to retrieve a soaking wet plush toy from my cat’s water bowl and drape it across the kitchen sink to dry out. I won’t even get into the fact that her favourite, pink fuzzy toy was resting inside her food bowl and now smells of stale, dry kibble.


You see, LooLoo is a recent addition and this need to drown her much-adored squeaky isn’t something I’ve experienced in the past with my other feline lodgers.


Is it because she’s female and most of my other fur crew have been male? Is it something specific to the Maine Coon cat that other breeds aren’t predisposed to? Is her intent malice? Or a bid to help her plush toy drink, eat, and thrive? Many questions… and some interesting answers.


While we all know that cats get the zoomies at night, wandering the halls and articulating their thoughts in a rather guttural manner, I wondered if this same nocturnal compulsion might be related to the late-night dunking of LooLoo’s arsenal of toys. I should note that none of these shenanigans take place during waking hours.


The answer is yes, it well could be connected to her need to hunt, capture, and kill. You see, cats are naturally nocturnal. Hence their need to sleep during the day to rest up for those nighttime expeditions. It doesn’t matter that she’s well-fed and snoozing soundly when you head to bed. The moment the lights go out, instincts kick in and she’s on the prowl.


Capturing her plush toy and depositing it into water or food could, in her mind, simply be a way to hide her newly caught prey from other predators. If she diminishes the scent, it may be less likely to be scooped up by another of my pets.


She might also be “stashing” it someplace she considers to be safe so that she can come back for it later. Hmmm…. wonder how she feels about me retrieving it.


Remember, animals are driven by instinct and as a feline, she may feel it necessary to clean her newly “caught” prey prior to eating it. While she will never consume her toys, this need to wash them after capture could be an innate characteristic she feels compelled to act on.


Now, another option tossed out there is the cats feel a need to gather items and have a central place for everything. I nixed this one pretty quickly for LooLoo. She has a little toy chest she likes to raid each day and scatter her collection far and wide. No, I think the “gathering” gene skipped this feline.


And lastly, she may be trying to show off her hunting skills. She’s proud of how she’s managed to wrangle her soft toys, disable them, and leave them in a publicly visible space for me to see. Note to self: be sure to shoot a little praise her way the next time I remove a dripping-wet toy from her bowl and head off to the kitchen.

Mary Simpson
Mary Simpson

Sharing space with three seriously judgy Schnoodles and 2 felines who prefers to be left alone. #LivingMyBestLife

More by Mary Simpson

Next