Help! My Dog is Aggressive Over Toys! What Now?

Britt
by Britt
Photo credit: Przemek Iciak / Shutterstock.com

Is your once-playful pup turning into a snarling toy hoarder? Do they become possessive anytime your family or other pets come near their favorite squeaky toy?


Dog aggression over toys can range from mild guarding to full-blown attacks. It’s a common problem – one that can be frustrating and sometimes scary to experience. The best thing you can do for your furry friend is to tackle the issue as soon as you notice the first signs of trouble.


In this guide, I’ll share tips and tricks to turn your toy-obsessed pup into a more social and relaxed companion. It’s not easy and won’t be solved overnight, but it is possible!


Understanding Resource Guarding


Resource guarding is a common behavior that many dog parents struggle with. It happens when a dog protects a resource they see as valuable from a perceived threat. This is a deeply rooted survival instinct, ensuring they have access to the resources needed to meet their basic needs. While this describes the reason for the behavior, it can become problematic if it escalates to aggression.


Common triggers for resource guarding include food, toys, bones, bedding, and specific locations within the home. Dogs may also guard people, especially “their person.”


The intensity of resource guarding can vary wildly. Some dogs will exhibit mild displays of possessiveness. Mild resource guarding may involve growling, snapping, or posturing when a person or other animal approaches the resource.


However, others will display severe aggression to protect what they see as theirs. This can involve aggressive biting and can pose a serious risk to others. Recognizing the signs of resource guarding and taking appropriate steps to address the issue before it escalates is crucial.


Preventing and Managing Toy Aggression


Once you have identified that your dog is exhibiting toy aggression, it’s time to take proactive steps to prevent and manage this behavior. After all, we all want to create a safe and happy living environment for our dogs and the rest of the family. The earlier you address the issue, the easier it will be to modify your dog’s behavior.


In the following sections, I’ll offer strategies and techniques to help you prevent and manage toy aggression that I have learned over my many years fostering rescue dogs. By understanding the underlying reasons for this behavior, managing the behavior to prevent trouble short-term, and training for long-term success, you can effectively address this common problem.


Early Socialization and Training


One of the most effective ways to prevent resource guarding is through early socialization and training, which is excellent news if you’re bringing a young puppy home!


Expose your young pup to various people, animals, and environments from a young age. This will help them develop positive associations with different triggers and situations, ultimately reducing their fear and anxiety. It will help them be more comfortable in unknown situations instead of making them feel like they have to step up and protect themselves and their treasured belongings.


Positive Reinforcement Techniques


Choosing the right approach to training is almost as important as the training process itself. Positive reinforcement is a powerful training method that rewards desired behaviors and creates positive associations.


When your dog displays calm and relaxed behavior around their toys, reward them with treats, praise, or playtime. In time, your dog will begin associating sharing with positive things, reducing the likelihood of aggressive behavior.


Why specifically positive reinforcement? Punishing or scolding your dog for guarding their toys can escalate their anxiety, making the problem worse.


Basic Obedience Commands


In addition to focusing on training specifically related to your dog’s resource guarding behaviors, you should continue working on obedience training. Many basic commands, such as “drop it” and “leave it,” will help you manage these situations.


Throughout this training, the goal is to convince your dog to trade for something better. Practice these commands regularly, starting with having your dog leave low-value items in exchange for treats. As they show they are more willing to make the trade, gradually progress to higher-value items like toys.


You can effectively prevent and manage their resource guarding by teaching your dog to hand over or drop items on cue.


Desensitization and Counterconditioning


An extension of your dog’s training, desensitization and counterconditioning are powerful techniques used to help your dog overcome their fear and anxiety. As these feelings can trigger resource guarding or make a situation involving resource guarding even worse, they are important to acknowledge and address.


If you have a dog who can share with others in some situations and not others, you will need to find the reason why. If your dog is in a situation where they are feeling fearful, they are more likely to try to feel the need to protect their belongings.  


These techniques involve gradually exposing your dog to their triggers while maintaining a calm and relaxed environment. These exposures are paired with positive reinforcement, such as treats or praise, to create positive associations and teach them that the trigger does not need to be feared.


For example, if you have a small dog afraid of large dogs, you may start by standing across a field from larger dogs while rewarding your dog for staying calm. Over time, you can slowly close the gap between them while praising and rewarding them for calm behavior. Eventually, your dog will be able to be close to larger dogs without feeling nervous or afraid because the emotions they feel when seeing them have been rewired – feeling excitement for the rewards they know they will receive instead of fear.


When you have successfully worked through this process, your dog will no longer feel the need to guard their toys just because a larger dog comes near.


Try Calming Products to Reduce Anxiety


For dogs who experience heightened anxiety or stress, calming products can help them feel more relaxed temporarily while you work toward a longer-term solution. Calming treats infused with natural ingredients like chamomile or valerian root can help soothe your dog and promote relaxation.


Another option is to use pheromone diffusers or sprays to mimic the calming pheromones that dogs naturally produce. These chemical signals tell the brain they are safe and secure, helping them feel calmer and relaxed in their surroundings. This can help prevent situations from escalating into something serious.


For more severe cases of anxiety, I recommend consulting with your veterinarian about the potential benefits of CBD products specifically formulated for dogs.

Photo credit: Chendongshan / Shutterstock.com

Creating a Calm and Structured Environment


One aspect of preventing resource guarding issues that is often overlooked is the impact of a dog’s environment on their behavior. If your dog lives in a high-stress, high-anxiety environment, they will be going into their daily interactions already feeling on edge. This makes it more likely that your dog will jump to an aggressive outburst.


Establish a routine and stick to it as much as possible. Provide your dog with plenty of mental enrichment and physical exercise to give them a positive outlet for their energy.


If you have multiple pets, feed them in separate locations. This will help you avoid creating a competitive atmosphere during mealtimes where your dog feels they must protect their food. Supervise your pets carefully during playtime to minimize the risk of conflict. If you see your dog getting too amped up during toy play, separate them from the situation and give them time to calm down.


Avoid Potentially Triggering Situations


No one knows your dog better than you. This includes knowing what situations are more likely to trigger your dog’s aggression and which resources they are more likely to try to protect. With this knowledge, you can prevent trouble by avoiding the situations before they start.


For example, if you know your dog will go to extreme lengths to protect stuffed toys, you should put any plush toys up and away before playtime with other dogs. This will set your dog up for success in their interactions with others. Other situations may involve changing your dog’s feeding routine, restricting access to certain areas of your home, or limiting their interactions with other dogs.


Don’t be afraid to advocate for your dog to prevent a situation from going south. If you have a dog who is protective of their favorite toy, don’t allow house guests to randomly pick this item up. Pay careful attention to these treasured items when children are around.


Be mindful of your dog’s body language. If you see that a situation is escalating their anxiety or aggression, remove them from the scenario promptly.


Maintain Regular Veterinary Check-Ups


Some medication conditions, such as pain or illness, can make dogs more irritable and protective of their resources. This makes it incredibly important to stay on top of your dog’s annual veterinary check-ups. These appointments allow your vet to catch problems early before they are allowed to progress and create significant pain and discomfort. The earlier medical conditions are identified, the better the prognosis.


Between appointments, pay careful attention to your dog’s behavior. Take note if you notice any significant changes or uncharacteristic signs of aggression or irritation. Call your vet to discuss your concerns if the behavior continues without a reasonable explanation.

When Should You Seek Professional Help?


If you’ve tried various management strategies like those outlined above and still struggle to manage your dog’s resource guarding, it may be time to reach out to a professional dog trainer or behaviorist.


There is no shame in asking for help! These professionals have more experience, knowledge, and expertise in handling these situations, allowing them to provide specialized guidance, targeted recommendations, and effective training techniques focused on your dog’s specific needs. If you have questions, don’t be afraid to ask. As professionals, they have seen it all, and I promise they aren’t judging you for trying to do the best you can for your dog.


A professional will likely start by assessing the severity of your dog’s resource guarding behavior. They will then work to identify the underlying causes and develop a training and behavior modification plan to set you and your dog up for success.


Initially, your trainer or behaviorist will work with you to teach you effective training techniques and help you understand your dog’s body language and communication signals. You can gain valuable insights and tools to address your dog’s behavior challenges by working closely with them. Remember, behavior modification takes time, patience, and consistency. It’s important to follow your trainer’s recommendations and practice the techniques they teach you regularly. Don’t get discouraged if you don’t see immediate results.


As you start seeing success, they will provide you with techniques and exercises to continue working with your dog as you move forward toward a happy life with your dog.

Final Thoughts: How to Address Toy Aggression in Your Dog Today


Resource guarding, particularly over toys, is a common problem for dog parents. However, with early intervention, careful management, consistent training, and positive reinforcement techniques, you can address the problem and create a safe and harmonious living environment for everyone involved (including your pup).


Remember, the key is to address the issue as soon as you notice signs that your dog feels they have to guard something they believe is valuable. By following the tips above, from creating a calm home environment to seeking professional help if needed, you can help your dog overcome resource guarding. This can help them become more relaxed and help them comfortably share their most prized possessions with others, including their toys!


Are you looking for more information or need personalized guidance?


Don’t hesitate to contact a professional dog trainer or behaviorist, especially if you feel the situation is escalating to the point of creating dangerous situations. They can provide a customized training plan to address your dog’s needs and set you both up for long-term success.


Remember: While resource guarding is frustrating, addressing these behaviors isn’t impossible. It will take time, energy, and commitment, but your dog is worth it.


Join the PetGuide community. Get the latest pet news and product recommendations by subscribing to our newsletter here.

Britt
Britt

Britt Kascjak is a proud pet mom, sharing her heart (and her home) with her “pack” which includes her husband John, their 2 dogs – Lucifer and Willow – and their 2 cats – Pippen and Jinx. She has been active in the animal rescue community for over 15 years, volunteering, fostering and advocating for organizations across Canada and the US. In her free time, she enjoys traveling around the country camping, hiking, and canoeing with her pets.

More by Britt

Next